“Our ancestral lands embody not only physical territory but the soul and history of our people.”
—Datu Sukanda, customary leader of the Cek Bocek Selesek Reen Sury community
For the Cek Bocek Indigenous community of Sumbawa, Indonesia, the Elang Dodo Forest is more than land earmarked for copper and gold extraction. It is part of their customary territory, sustaining livelihoods, cultural practices, and relationships with ancestral burial sites. Yet the community’s recognition and territorial rights remain contested.
A new Tallgrass Institute case study, When Assurance Fails Indigenous Peoples: The Cek Bocek Case and The Copper Mark, examines what this dispute reveals about voluntary mining assurance systems and their ability to protect Indigenous Peoples’ rights.
The case centres on two projects controlled by PT Amman Mineral Nusa Tenggara (PT AMNT): the operating Batu Hijau copper-gold mine and planned Elang Project, approximately 60 kilometres apart. Although separate, AMMAN intends to use Batu Hijau’s processing and other infrastructure for ore from Elang.
Batu Hijau received The Copper Mark in July 2024. The assurance applies to Batu Hijau, not Elang, where many of the community’s concerns are concentrated. The Cek Bocek allege that activities affecting their customary territory proceeded without free, prior and informed consent (FPIC), and have raised concerns about Indigenous recognition, access to land, and impacts on ancestral sites.
On August 9, 2025, community representatives submitted a formal grievance to The Copper Mark. Following a September 2025 assessment, AMMAN announced in November that Batu Hijau “Fully meets” all applicable criteria. On December 2, 2025, The Copper Mark found the grievance admissible, while Batu Hijau’s assurance remained in place.
The case does not establish that the assurance decision breached its rules. It asks whether site-level assurance can credibly signal responsible production when significant rights concerns linked to the same operator remain unresolved.
The case offers lessons for the emerging Veramark Global Mining Standard: credible assurance must make unresolved rights concerns visible, not obscure them behind site-level claims. The report concludes:
For voluntary assurance to provide credible information about Indigenous Peoples’ rights, its conclusions need to reflect both the systems a company has established and what those systems have produced in practice. Where rights remain seriously disputed, the assurance result should make that uncertainty visible rather than allowing it to disappear within an overall performance claim.
Key Findings
Reviewing company policies and procedures does not necessarily demonstrate that Indigenous Peoples’ rights are respected in practice.
Site-level assurance can exclude related development projects, even where they share infrastructure and the same operator.
Contested State recognition can affect whether communities are identified and engaged as Indigenous rights-holders.
A “Fully meets” assessment and an unresolved grievance can coexist, potentially obscuring material concerns.
An assurance mark is not a substitute for independent human rights due diligence.
Recommendations for Assurance Schemes and Standard-Setters
Make assessment boundaries, exclusions, and material connected risks transparent.
Independently verify Indigenous Peoples’ rights and collective FPIC processes, not only stakeholder interviews or company documentation.
Establish clear triggers for reviewing, qualifying, or suspending claims when credible grievances raise material concerns.
Require a minimum threshold on Indigenous Peoples’ rights before granting responsible-production performance claims.
Priorities for Investors, Buyers, and Civil Society
Review underlying assessment reports, active grievances, and the company’s activities beyond the assured site.
Seek information directly from affected Indigenous Peoples and their representative institutions.
Use purchasing and investment leverage to encourage meaningful engagement, resolution, and remedy.